Anyway, a message containing irony or its coarser brother, sarcasm, can be indicated as such by tone, pitch, or facial expression when heard and seen, This is not so easy when the medium is strictly print. Consider a simple sentence: "Good work, men." This can imply a simple praising of a group or (less often) a snide comment, like when a collective effort fails due to incompetence or overlooking something. In speech the hearer can gain a sense of the message; but in print no such reservations are communicated. This is the problem.
On the internet there is the convention that the use of capital letters is the equivalent of shouting, as: "READ THE MANUAL BEFORE USE" as opposed to the more subdued "Read the manual before use." We also need a way to communicate irony or sarcasm as well. Perhaps using something like italics, or boldface, or maybe different colored type would do. Or, we can just admit that irony or sarcasm doesn't easily fly well in written form when used by the unskilled. Jonathan Swift and Voltaire did manage well, though.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
And there's that unnecessary phrase, "Just sayin'." Where did this irritating expression come from? And what does this mean? Is this an attempt to say something snide or serious without assuming responsibility for ownership? Or is it just a means of filling space with sound? Recently, President Trump seems to use this expression a lot.
The one that irritates me is the "Give it up for....." when asking for applause for someone. Ugh!
ReplyDeleteIrony and sarcasm are difficult in print and equally dangerous from unskilled users and slow witted readers.
ReplyDeleteSometimes a well placed all caps can work depending on the sentence. But it has to be VERY well placed.
ReplyDelete'Grooming language' I call it. Not about idea-communication, but about bonding. [which the prez is furiously trying to stay with his big base of angry and idiots out there]
ReplyDeleteA fun and meaningful post to ponder!
The 'I'm just sayin' is grooming language, I mean. Sarcasm does take a talented writer to convey in print. Thou art correct
ReplyDeleteJust sayin' is so useless an expression.
ReplyDeleteIrony is a skill most have not learned how to do,
ReplyDeleteHow about "believe me" ???
ReplyDelete